Volume 23, Number
9, January - March 2009
Grahame Brown Memorial Issue - Part One
|
|
- List of published works
- Some personal reminiscences
- The many facets of Grahame Brown
- Sapphire-Ruby characteristics West Pailin, Cambodia
- Blue fluorescence in diamonds
- Opal similarities between Andamooka and Coober Pedy, South
Australia
- Nature and origin of the orbicular granodiorite from Boogardie
Station Western Australia
- Precision instrument readability - Your SG value may not be as
good as you think it is
|
(Follow this link for abstracts of past issues)
The Grahame Brown Memorial
Issue of the Association's journal, Part 1 is being published on the first
anniversary of Grahame's death and contains personal details, photographs,
reminiscences and papers authored by selected Australian authors. Grahame
has touched the lives of every GAA member, whether personally, by way of his
many lectures or through this journal to which he devoted so much time and
effort, with dedication, enthusiasm and specialised knowledge. Because of
the written word, the memory of Grahame Brown will live on for generations
to come.
Grant Pearson,
Editor
GRAHAME BROWN - LIST OF PUBLISHED
WORKS
some personal reminiscences
the many facets of grahame brown
- photo montage

sapphire - ruby characteristics
west pailin, cambodia - Clues to their origin based on trace element and o
isotope analysis
F.L. Sutherland1,5, G. Guiliani2, A.E.
Fallick3, M. Garland4, G. Webb5
1 School of Natural Sciences, University of Western Sydney
2 IRD UR154 LMTG Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique,
Vandoeuvre-les-Nancy, France
3 Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre, East
Kilbride, Scotland, UK
4 420 Wilkins St London, Ontario, N6C5B2, Canada
5 Geoscience, Australian Museum, 6 College St, Sydney, NSW, 2010
Australia
ABSTRACT
Trace element (Particle-induced X-ray emission) and oxygen isotope (ß18O)
analyses on West Pailin, Cambodian sapphires and rubies further constrain
the geochernical characteristics of this basalt-derived, bimodal (two
corundum types) gem deposit. The results confirm a clear distinction between
magmatic origin sapphires (Fe 2300-8000ppm, Ti 15-1800ppm, Cr below
detection, Ga 160-260ppm; Cr/Ga < 0.01; ß18O)
7.0-7.8 0/00) and metamorphic-origin sapphires and
rubies (Fe 3300-9130ppm, Ti 60-3600ppm, Cr 160-5300ppm, Ga 28-46ppm; Cr/Ga
3.6-155;
ß18O 4.0-4.9
0/00).
Comparisons with a similar Australian bimodal corundum deposit from the
Barrington Tops, basaltic gem field show some common features, although the
West Pailin magmatic suite is more depleted in Fe and noticeably higher in
ß18O values. The metamorphic suite is more enriched in Ti and Cr
and distinctly lower in its
ß18O range than its Barrington Tops counterpart. This allows
geographic distinctions to be drawn between these bimodal corundum suites
and indicates differences in the geological processes by which corundum
crystallised under the two regions.
Key-words: Sapphire, ruby, corundum, basalt field, trace elements,
oxygen isotopes, gemstone genesis, Southeast Asia, Eastern Australia.
BLUE FLUORESCENCE IN DIAMONDS
Garry Holloway
ABSTRACT
Historically 'blue white' fluorescent top coloured (D to F on the GIA colour
grading scale) diamonds were once priced around 10% more than non
fluorescent diamonds. Today, D to F coloured blue fluorescent diamonds are
usually discounted on wholesale markets. There are two main technical
reasons why fluorescent diamonds would be discounted. The diamond's body
colour may have been 'over-graded' or its transparency may have been
impaired.
There are also several possible "commercial" reasons why high coloured (DF)
blue fluorescent diamonds are often discounted. For example, they may be
more difficult to sell. This article will review the complex and often
contradictory history.
Key-words: diamond, fluorescence, transparency, hazy, nitrogen, blue.
OPAL SIMILARITIES BETWEEN
ANDAMOOKA
AND COOBER PEDY SOUTH AUSTRALIA
I. Jack Townsend, BSC, FGAA
ABSTRACT
Many would argue that opal from Andamooka and Coober Pedy is like chalk
and cheese and for much of the opal that is correct. In this paper
however I would like to focus on the similarities of some of the opal
from both fields and the reasons for the similarities. It is suggested
that there were similar geological environments at Andamooka and at the
southern Coober Pedy fields surrounding Allan Rise.
|
|

Painted Lady, Allan Rise, Coober Pedy
(Sample courtesy John Dunstan). |
NATURE AND ORIGIN OF THE
ORBICULAR GRANODIORITE
FROM BOOGARDIE STATION WESTERN AUSTRALIA:
AN ORNAMENTAL STONE OF MONUMENTAL PROPORTIONS
Jennifer C. Bevan1, and Alexander W. R. Bevan2
1 E.de C. Clarke Earth Science Museum, School of Earth
and Geographical Sciences, University of Western Australia
2 Department of Earth and Planetary Sciences,
Western Australian Museum, Western Australia
ABSTRACT
An occurrence of orbicular granodiorite on Boogardie Station, West Of
Mount Magnet in Western Australia is one of the oldest and largest of
its kind known. The origin and development of the orbicular texture
represents a complex, multi-stage series of mineral nucleation
reactions, and radial and concentric growth on nucleii within the parent
dioritic magma. This attractive orbicular rock has been used for a wide
variety of decorative and ornamental purposes, sometimes on a grand
scale. Products have included spheres, table tops, sculptures, and
building materials, such as tiles. Sliced and polished individual
orbicules have been used as coasters and decorative plaques. Although
currently not in operation, quarrying of the deposit has occurred
intermittently over the last twenty, years, and a proven lateral
extension of the limited deposit may ensure production of rough material
well into the future. |
|

A slab of orbicular granodiorite showing a range of
orbicule types. |
precision of instrument
readability:
your sg value may not be as good as you think it is!
Grant Pearson, Mt Waverley, Victoria
ABSTRACT
The sources and possible magnitudes of measurement uncertainty inherent in a
specimen's specific gravity are discussed when it was determined by the
hydrostatic Archimedes Principle. The factors that reduce or increase the
reliability of the determination were examined and the appropriate stone
sizes necessary to be able to derive a reliable result from a balance with a
specified readability were assessed. Small portable electronic balances may
not give the necessary precision for a definitive result on even larger
stones for identification purposes. Even measurements on a high precision
chemical balance cannot be relied upon for specific gravity values to better
than the second decimal place at best for stones of only a carat or so.
Key Words: Specific gravity, Uncertainty, readability, precision,
accuracy.
|